If you become the manager of your former colleagues, do not gloss over the role change but address it openly. Clarify early what changes and what stays, hold a one-to-one with each team member, and treat everyone equally, including the people you are friends with. The first weeks shape how you are perceived as a leader.
Why this change is particularly delicate
You know the team, its strengths, its conflicts and its unwritten rules. That is an advantage. At the same time the team knows you, including your weaknesses and where you stand on many issues in the department. Colleagues become direct reports, and relationships change whether you want them to or not. Some are pleased for you, others had hoped for the job themselves. Pretending that everything stays the same invites misunderstandings.
The first steps
- Name the change openly. Say in the first team meeting that your role has changed and that this is new for everyone. It takes tension out.
- Hold one-to-ones. Ask everyone what works well, what should change and what they expect from you. You gain information and show respect.
- Talk to rival candidates first. Anyone who hoped for the job deserves an early, honest conversation. Acknowledge their competence and clarify how you will work together.
- Send early signals deliberately. Your first decisions are watched closely. Choose them with care and explain them.
Reordering friendship and closeness
Friendships do not have to end, but they get a new boundary. Address this directly with close colleagues: you value the relationship, but you cannot grant advantages and will have to make uncomfortable decisions. The topics of conversation change too: you now learn confidential things, such as personnel matters or planned changes, that no longer belong in conversations among colleagues. Make sure nobody gets the impression that there is an inner circle. Small things have a big effect here: who you have lunch with, whom you inform first, whose suggestions you take up.
The new role upwards and sideways
The change also alters your relationships outside the team. You now sit at the table with other managers and represent your team upwards. Clarify with your own manager what they expect and how your success will be measured. And build relationships with your new peers at management level. From now on, this level is your most important network. The new level has its own, mostly unspoken rules: who is consulted before important meetings, whose word carries weight with divisional management, which topics are better raised one-to-one first? Watch closely in the first weeks before you commit yourself. Whoever knows these rules can represent their team more effectively.
What to avoid
- Turning everything upside down at once. Changing a lot straight away looks like a need to prove yourself.
- Talking the way you did among colleagues. As a manager you know more and your words carry more weight: what you say about decisions from above or about individuals is now heard differently.
- Avoiding conflict out of friendship. Not addressing problems quickly costs respect, even with those you meant to spare.
Conclusion
The move from colleague to manager succeeds when you shape it rather than keep quiet about it. Openness, fair treatment of everyone and clear signals in the first weeks lay the groundwork for trust in the new role. How the unwritten rules of organisations work in general is explained in What Is Office Politics?. If you want to prepare your start with an outside view, the 3-Month Coaching is a good fit.
Image: AI-generated
Do you recognise your situation?
Briefly describe your situation. I read every enquiry myself and usually reply within 24 hours on working days.
Request a consultationPersonal · confidential